News

SEND YOUR NEWSWORTHY VIDEOS TO VIDEOS@NEWSTALK1010.COM

UPDATE: Ministry Responds to Report TDSB Overcharged for Minor Work

Posted By: Russ Courtney · 6/21/2012 5:33:00 AM

Not long after Toronto District School Board trustees voted to explore selling parts of schoolyards to raise badly needed cash, there's news that the board has apparently been charged what appears to be outrageous amounts for work at schools.

A Toronto Star investigation reports that taxpayers were charged $143 dollars to install a pencil sharpener and $3,000 to put in an electrical outlet in a library.

The paper reports that the union with an exclusive contract to carry out work has at times billed many more hours than it took to complete projects. Taxpayers were billed 76 hours for the electrical outlet, which reportedly only took four hours to install.

The office of the Minister of Education sent an e-mail to reporter Amber Gero stating: "It is our expectation that boards make the best use of our public education dollars. We’ve been clear that we expect boards to focus spending on students and the classroom experience. Just like we have had to make choices as a government, boards also have a responsibility to make important decisions.

We look to all boards to makes choices that protect the gains we've made together including lower class sizes, full-day kindergarten and more teachers and support staff in our schools. The TDSB has acknowledged this as a concern and we are pleased the board is taking steps to address this issue."

The union boss tells the Star the billings were because of "clerical errors" and says much of the money has been refunded to the schools.

There are 900 electricians, carpenters, maintenance workers, and plumbers that are paid by the TDSB, but highly influenced by the union that represents them.

The Toronto Catholic District School Board (about half the size of the TDSB) has 70 full-time workers with some tasks contracted out.

The board recently approved a budget with $109 million dollars in budget cuts that one trustee called a "bloodbath"

In an e-mail response sent to Newstalk 1010's Amber Gero, former Toronto District School Board trustee and current City Councillor, Josh Matlow, wrote:  "The TDSB must get real about this.  There are school facilities across Toronto in disrepair while their trades fees far exceed what's found in the private sector.  This isn't fair to students or their parents."

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
Comment Like
  • 14
  1. DougZ_5671 posted on 06/21/2012 08:16 AM
    Why are you guys afraid to call a spade a spade. This is a case of theft by the union bosses. Until some heads roll and people go to jail this fisco will continue. This is a culture that has been in place for years and many people have turned a blind eye. In the meatime the kids and the tax payers are getting screwed.
  2. D2x posted on 06/21/2012 09:09 AM
    28 coat hooks installed for $2300.00. 5 safety mirrors installed $5200.00
    Cost for the hooks $100.00 and the rest...
    Cost for the safety mirrors $$600.00 and the rest...
  3. P posted on 06/21/2012 09:27 AM
    Doesn't suprise me...Once worked for a company that rented space from the TDSB and when they wanted to paint the facility they had to use TDSB painters and they wanted over $10,000 to paint about 1500 sq ft of wall space! TDSB overcharges for EVERYTHING!
  4. proton posted on 06/21/2012 09:28 AM
    price to install an electrical outlet...$3,000
    price to install a pencil sharpener... $ 143
    having the luxury of a non-competitive contract to do TDSB's work and screw the taxpayers.......PRICELESS!!! (acknowledgment to MasterCard for the original ad)

    GRAVY TRAIN!!!

    Another perfect example of why government shouldn't be running things.
  5. Peter posted on 06/21/2012 10:28 AM
    Shame on all of the trustees at the TDSB. It is not possible they were not aware this type of abuse was going on. Also, shame on all the politicians who continue to be afraid to make the right decisions to eliminate this kind of excessive waste. This is simply glorified union welfare.
  6. proton posted on 06/21/2012 11:23 AM
    this is the same attitude and pro-union snow job toronto taxpayers faced under miller, where jobs only went to union "fair" wage nonsense.

    no wonder there's not enough money for what needs to be done.
  7. newton posted on 06/21/2012 11:32 AM
    The TDSB contracts out a great deal of its work. They have lots of CUPE workers at 24/hr, but they can't do the jobs. Contracting out is costing the TDSB a fortune.
    1. palma posted on 06/22/2012 10:04 PM
      @newton 900 electricians, carpenters, maintenance workers, and plumbers and you are saying they contract out a lot of their work? You have got to be kidding
  8. Rick posted on 06/21/2012 02:10 PM
    Who ever is incharge of theis so called, "clerical" error MUST be charged with embezzlement. And the contractor who accepted the monies and said nothing about the error seems like someone with no ethical stance
    1. James posted on 06/22/2012 09:42 AM
      @Rick Charges and firings are a must at this point.

      Decertifying this disgusting union should be a high priority also.
    2. palma posted on 06/22/2012 10:02 PM
      @Rick And you actually believe the clerical error line?
  9. DoloresF posted on 06/21/2012 03:04 PM
    This has been going on for years. I worked in an elementary school years ago and a friend of my husband came to the school. I asked him if he was there to fix an electrical problem and he told me he wasn't allowed to because he was a plumber.
    Go figure. No wonder the school board is in trouble.
  10. cj posted on 06/26/2012 02:25 PM
    You should also check into the boards buying policy where schools have to use certain companies to make purchases from, and pay much higher prices than competitors, Eg, We have to buy office supplies from Grand and Toy at 50% off their catalogued price. This price is exactly the same as any one can get off their online catalogue. Staples is substantially cheaper. But we are not allowed to buy from them, Once again contracts are signed with companies and teachers have to over pay, and our limited budgets are diminished faster.There are many examples of this going on.
showing all comments

Videos

Trending