News

SEND YOUR NEWSWORTHY VIDEOS TO VIDEOS@NEWSTALK1010.COM

Libel case against Rob Ford dismissed

Posted By: Siobhan Morris · 12/27/2012 6:41:00 PM

It's a legal victory for Rob Ford.

The $6-million defamation lawsuit against the mayor of Toronto has been thrown out of court.

Ontario Superior Court Justice John Macdonald has ruled that the suit filed by Boardwalk Pub owner George Foulidis, didn't meet the "essential aspects" of a libel claim.

In his 15-page decision, Macdonald says Foulidis didn't prove that Ford's comments to the Toronto Sun editorial board in 2010 were directed at him or that they were defamatory.

Foulidis sued Ford, alleging that the then mayoral candidate had suggested a sole-sourced, untendered, 20-year lease deal between Foulidis's company, Tuggs Inc. & the city was corrupt &"stinks to high heaven".

Speaking with Joe Warmington as he guest-hosted Newstalk 1010's Friendly Fire, Foulidis' lawyer says he's still digesting the decision.  Brian Shiller says Foulidis' team presented their case in a very straightforward manner& the judge felt the facts didn't support their point of view.

Rob Ford has released a statement:

"I welcome today’s decision by the Court to dismiss the Foulidis lawsuit against me.  I will continue fighting to represent the best interests of Toronto taxpayers at City Hall. There is still a lot of work to be done and I will continue to focus on this."

Foulidis has 30 days to file an appeal but as of Thursday night, no decision had been made about whether he will.

The Boardwalk Pub owner argued in court that his reputation had been hurt by Ford's comments.

In the ruling, Justice Macdonald suggests a reasonable person wouldn't have linked them to Foulidis, rather than the company.  The judge also points out that Ford didn't know Foulidis by name.

Justice Macdonald has some harsh words for George Foulidis in his ruling, saying that he had "attempted to mislead" the court "about his past fraudulent conduct".  Macdonald writes that he was left with "serious doubt about the credibility and reliability of his testimony".

Brian Shiller didn't want to comment on the judge's words with an appeal still possible but he did leap to his client's defence.  He says Foulidis is a "hard-working, honest businessman" who "has taken a lot of cheap shots" in recent years.  Shiller says describing the Boardwalk Pub agreement as a "cushy deal" just isn't true.

Despite the win, the mayor's legal woes aren't over.  An appeal of a conflict of interest ruling that has Ford on his way out as mayor will be heard January 7th.  A forensic audit his campaign expense is also expected next month.

Read the judge's full decision here.

(With files from the Canadian Press)

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
Comment Like
  • 13
  1. Jim posted on 12/27/2012 06:06 PM
    This is certainly a great verdict, great outcome. I'm sure the Ford detractors will be out in full force now, wait for it! The best part though is imagining how ticked Adam Vaughan, Shelly Carroll, Pam McConnell et al are.
  2. Storm posted on 12/27/2012 06:53 PM
    You can't be charged or sued for slander when you say the truth. All Ford did was say that a stinky deal stunk. Now I look forward to the other case to be reversed in appeal as it is a trivial sum, politically motivated, and not worth taking out a popular fairly elected Mayor.
    1. Jim posted on 12/27/2012 07:06 PM
      @Storm And just think how steamed all the Ford haters are going to be. Should be interesting.
  3. judge darwin posted on 12/27/2012 08:02 PM
    Call in the Health Inspectors..smells like Foul-idis' been flinging poop from his kitchen
  4. proton posted on 12/28/2012 12:06 AM
    i hope the judge rules that foulidis pays ALL legal charges. everyone who thinks the deal he struck for the restaurant stinks should avoid eating there.
  5. Only Common Sense posted on 12/28/2012 07:58 AM
    Good call on the judge's behalf.
    The principal witness against Ford was obviously not credible.
    The next time that the Adam Vaughn types of the world try engineering something this blatant and stupid, they should be included in the payment of all the legal fees incurred.
    Yes, Ford was guilty of sloppy talk ... not defamation.
    To all you Ford haters ... there are a few things out there worth your wrath against the mayor, without doubt ... but have the "gonads" to do something head-on instead of by proxy.
    1. jim posted on 12/28/2012 11:40 AM
      @Only Common Sense I don't think "wrath" is quite the right word, there are definitely things he needs to address, but he really has done nothing to bring "wrath" from all of these haters and there has been something ugly things said about him. Whatever he has done that wasn't "kosher" he has paid for in spades and paid for in ways that he didn't deserve and for reasons that weren't even real. If and when he wins his appeal and once agian is firmly ensconced a the mayor, i hope all of his detractors back off, take a long hard look at the rest of the council and act accordingly.
  6. CoffeeCon posted on 12/28/2012 10:33 AM
    Awful quiet around here from all the Ford libellers that are usually hanging about. Hmm.
  7. Ken posted on 12/28/2012 01:20 PM
    So let me get this straight. A commie socialist newspaper (Toronto Star) makes up a quote and reports that it was made by the Mayor.

    They then contract a fellow commie socialist (making all income off inside deals with the State) to sue the Mayor for the quotes they made up and published.

    So North Korean or Iranian!
showing all comments

Videos

Trending