Supreme Court makes landmark ruling on Native land rights

The decision will essentially make it easier for First Nations to establish title over lands that were regularly used for hunting, fishing and other activities.

For the first time, the Supreme Court of Canada has recognized a First Nation's title to a specific tract of land -- a historic decision with major implications for contentious energy projects such as the Northern Gateway pipeline.

Thursday's 8-0 decision, which overturned an appeal court ruling, will essentially make it easier for First Nations to establish title over lands that were regularly used for hunting, fishing and other activities.

The landmark ruling is the Supreme Court's first on aboriginal title and will apply wherever there are unresolved land claims.

"The claimant group bears the onus of establishing aboriginal title," Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin wrote in the decision.

"The task is to identify how pre-sovereignty rights and interests can properly find expression in modern common law terms."

Title, however, is not absolute, the top court declared; economic development can still go ahead on land where title is established as long as one of two conditions is met.

Economic development on land where title is established would require the consent of the First Nation. Failing that, the government would have to make the case that development is pressing and substantial and meet its fiduciary duty to the aboriginal group.

In other words, the decision places a greater burden on governments to justify economic development on aboriginal land.

The court also makes it clear that provincial law still applies to land over which aboriginal title has been declared, subject to constitutional limits.

Chief Roger William of Xeni Gwet'in, one of six bands that make up the Tsilhqot'in First Nation, said he welcomed the Supreme Court's decision to grant a recognition of aboriginal title to 1,750 square kilometres of territory.

"First Nations across this country have taken legal action, entered into treaty, practised their language and demonstrated use of the land and through this they have supported us -- we thank you," he said in a statement.

The case dates back to the early 1990s, when the Tsilhqot'in First Nation first began using the courts and a blockade to stop logging operations in the area, setting off a two-decade legal odyssey that has cost tens of millions of dollars.

The Tsilhqot'in, whose territory is near Williams Lake, B.C., is made up of six aboriginal bands that together include about 3,000 people.

One of those bands, the Xeni Gwet'in, claimed aboriginal title over two areas it considered its traditional land. A forestry company attempted to secure access to those areas beginning in 1980s, eventually setting off the current court case.

In May of 1992, the Tsilhqot'in staged a blockade to prevent work on a bridge related to proposed forestry activity, which ended when then-premier Mike Harcourt promised there would be no further logging in the area without the consent of the Xeni Gwet'in.

Much of the area in dispute was turned into a provincial park in 1994, but the band and the province have been fighting over the remaining land ever since. The area at the centre of the court case represents about five per cent of what Tsilhqot'in band considers its traditional territory.

The trial, which began in November 2002 and continued for nearly five years, heard evidence that the Tsilhqot'in have been present in the area for more than 250 years.

But the trial also heard the Tsilhqot'in were "semi-nomadic," with few permanent encampments, even though they saw the area as their own and protected it from outsiders.

Jody Wilson-Raybould, British Columbia regional chief for the Assembly of First Nations, called Thursday's decision a "game changer." Unlike other provinces, British Columbia does not have modern-day treaties with its First Nations, so the ruling has significant implications.

"The court has clearly sent a message that the Crown must take aboriginal title seriously and reconcile with First Nations honourably," she said in a statement.

"The decision is an opportunity to truly settle, once and for all, the land question in B.C. -- where our nations are not simply making claims to the Crown under an outdated federal policy but where there must be true reconciliation based on recognition and where the outcome of negotiations is certain."

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
  1. don was right posted on 06/27/2014 09:35 AM
    now if they would start paying taxes everything woudl be great
    1. sam sahm posted on 06/29/2014 10:05 AM
      @don was right be great if you could lose your archaic way of thinking...perhaps now your side of the coin can start paying for having your way with other people's possessions...not likely though..
  2. Frankie posted on 06/27/2014 09:51 AM
    Forget paying taxes, just wait until they start making land claims in downtown Vancouver and other major cities across Canada. This is the tip of an iceberg that will engulf this country in disaster.
  3. Canadian or not posted on 06/27/2014 12:46 PM
    We should give those leeches an ultimatum: Assimilate into Canadian culture with no special priveliges or exemptions like everyone else, or be cut off completely from all Canadian aid, money, and supplies. Blockade the reserves, and see how long they can survive on "the old ways".
    1. sam sahm posted on 06/29/2014 10:08 AM
      @Canadian or not goes for you too..leeches just got your for you and your ancestors mistakes, or stick your head back up your a$$ and go back to the country your forefathers got ran out of..
    2. Mark7 posted on 06/29/2014 10:26 AM
      @Canadian or not "Assimilate into Canadian culture with no special privileges or exemptions like everyone else"

      Who the hell you trying to fool? Show me who assimilates into our culture. Just go on any TTC bus and if you are lucky, you MIGHT find someone speaking English. So many come here never intending to learn our language. They instead try to change our laws to their liking with great success.

      As for the native Indians. EVERYTHING YOU HAVE IN WAY OF LAND WAS STOLEN FROM THEM. Canada belongs to the natives, we are just trespassing. That is the cold, hard facts, like it or not!
showing all comments

Sign Up For Breaking News Alerts

Becoming a member only takes 60 seconds! Members get access to exclusive information and products that non-members do not, including concert ticket presales, trips, advance notice on upcoming entertainment events, movie screening passes, music giveaways and more!

Login with Facebook

Stay connected 24/7! Receive breaking news and programming alerts right to your inbox. CLICK HERE to sign-up.

Today's Poll

Toronto Police have revised its policy on carding but it will remain a tool for officers to use. Chief Bill Blair calls it an "essential means to preventing crime" Do you agree?

Voting is restricted to one vote every 24 hour(s) VoteResults

Top Stories