JERRY AGAR

A Canadian silver, rightly earned

Posted By: Jerry Agar · 8/5/2012 9:10:00 AM

Ryan Cochrane won silver in the 1,500 meter swim. That's a killer race and he killed all but one in the competition.

China's Sun Yang was nearly disqualified when he entered the pool ahead of the start. It is not the first race in the competition that saw a swimmer jump the gun and win the right to continue. But some are saying that Sun should have been disqualified, which would have given the gold to Cochrane.

Sun set a world record and beat Cochrane by an amazing seven seconds and change. Sun was incredible, so was Cochrane, but Sun was better.

If a runner comes up lame during a race, if a trampoline jumper (when did that get to be a sport?) falls on her butt, or a competitor is sick, then someone else wins. That is the reality of sport.

But to take the gold because someone in the audience made a noise and startled Sun into the pool, would be a gold for Cochrane and Canada, but not an indication that he is the "best in the world." There is more pride in the silver he won than getting a gold that way.

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
  1. LindaO posted on 08/06/2012 04:24 AM
    I totally agree with your comments. There is much more pride in winning the Silver than winning the Gold had Sun been disqualified. Truly, Sun seemed to be in a class all of his own and rightly deserved the Gold. Truth is, it's just as difficult to win a Silver or a Bronze than it is to win a Gold. So many wonderful athletes, so few medals!!!
  2. Richard Collins posted on 08/07/2012 08:31 AM
    Well-said! I was watching that race too, and the commentators there made a good point about how an advantage in the beginning doesn't necessarily translate into an advantage at the end of the grueling, 30-pool-length swim.
  3. CoffeeCon posted on 08/07/2012 05:18 PM
    Clearly we need to liberalize this competition. There are so many who just don't feel included in the medal ceremony. Their feelings must be accommodated!
  4. anninl_9110 posted on 10/09/2012 09:46 PM
    North Face Ultralight Tents:North Face Ultralight Tents include north face jackets cheap Tadpole 23, Particle 13 and Vector 22, with price ranging from $200 to $230. All the three models are constructed with Waterproof Flysheet technology, with 40 denier 240T nylon north face sale canopy and 70 denier 210T nylon taffeta floor.
showing all comments